Most questions in a community association come down to one point: which document decides the matter? A fence request, a pool schedule and a board election each answer to a different governing document. In Pennsylvania, state law also sets the order in which those documents apply.

Below, we explain what each document controls, which one wins in a conflict, and how boards and homeowners can use them with confidence.

What Are an Association’s Governing Documents?

Governing documents are the papers that set how a community association owns land, makes choices and runs daily life. Most HOAs and condos in Pennsylvania rely on three core documents: the declaration, the bylaws and the rules and regulations. All three sit under state law.

Many associations also hold:

Planned communities follow the Uniform Planned Community Act. Condos follow the Uniform Condominium Act. Both treat these documents in much the same way.

What Does the Declaration Control?

The declaration is the founding document. It creates the community and sets each owner’s property rights. Many people call it the CC&Rs. It sits on record with the county Recorder of Deeds, so it binds every owner, now and in the future.

Under 68 Pa.C.S. § 5205, a declaration must address:

That expense share matters every month. It sets each owner’s part of the budget and forms the base of sound community association financial management in PA.

What Do the Bylaws Cover?

Bylaws explain how the HOA runs as a group. The declaration says what the community is. The bylaws say how it makes choices.

The Planned Community Act says bylaws must state:

Bylaws also tend to cover the annual meeting, quorum, proxies and notice. When an election stalls or someone questions a meeting, start with the bylaws.

What Role Do Rules and Regulations Play?

Rules guide daily conduct and the use of shared spaces. State law lets the HOA adopt and change rules, so the board can pass most of them by its own vote, with no owner vote needed.

Typical rules address:

So, can the board change pool hours without an owner vote? In most communities, yes, if the declaration and bylaws give it that power. A rule cannot create a limit the declaration does not support, though. A board should confirm its power before it writes the rule, not after an owner objects.

Which Document Wins When They Conflict?

State law comes first, then the declaration, then the bylaws, then the rules. Pennsylvania spells out part of this order. If the declaration and bylaws clash, the declaration wins, unless it clashes with the Act itself (§ 5203(c)).

RankDocumentWhat it controls
1Pennsylvania lawOwner rights and steps no document can override
2DeclarationProperty rights, expense shares, limits on use
3Articles of incorporation (if any)The HOA’s legal status as a corporation
4BylawsBoard structure, elections, meetings
5Rules and regulationsDaily use of shared spaces

Here is how that plays out. Say a board wants to limit rentals. A new rule may feel faster, but limits on how owners use their homes belong in the declaration. A rule alone invites a challenge.

How Can Each Document Be Changed?

Each document changes through its own process. The higher the document ranks, the more owners must agree.

DocumentWho approvesRequirement in Pennsylvania
DeclarationOwnersAt least 67% of the HOA’s votes, then recording with the county (§ 5219)
BylawsOwnersThe method the bylaws set; the Act’s default is 51% of the votes
RulesBoardA board vote, within the power the declaration and bylaws give

Some changes need more. Changing unit lines, an owner’s expense share or allowed uses needs the consent of every owner affected. Bring in the HOA’s attorney before anyone drafts a change.

How Should Boards and Homeowners Use These Documents Day to Day?

Start with a three-question test:

  1. Does it involve property, money, or how owners may use a home? Open the declaration.
  2. Does it involve votes, meetings, or board power? Open the bylaws.
  3. Does it involve daily conduct in shared spaces? Open the rules.

Buyers get all three documents in the resale package, which the HOA must provide within 10 days of an owner’s request. Homeowners planning an exterior change can send our architectural request form before work begins.

As a community management company in PA, we keep these documents in order, apply them the same way to every owner and flag legal questions for the board’s attorney. Our community association accounting services in Phoenixville bill each home’s share as the declaration sets it, so the numbers match the documents.

What Should Your Board Remember?

Governing documents form a chain of command. The declaration defines the community, the bylaws run the group and the rules guide daily life. When a board reads them in that order and stays within each one’s limits, its choices hold up and owners see a fair process.

Need Help Applying Your Association’s Governing Documents?

Diamond Community Services works with HOA, planned community and condominium boards across Chester and Montgomery Counties. We provide community association management in Royersford, Phoenixville and nearby towns, with board-controlled accounts and support at every board meeting. Call (610) 948-1155 or request a proposal to get started.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do HOA governing documents apply to tenants?

In most communities, yes. Declarations and rules often extend to tenants and guests, and the owner stays responsible for their breaches.

Does the Uniform Planned Community Act apply to communities created before 1997?

Partly. Key sections, such as the conflict rule, the amendment process, records access and resale packages, also apply to older planned communities.

Does every association have articles of incorporation?

No. Pennsylvania lets an HOA form as a corporation or as an unincorporated group. Only incorporated HOAs file articles.

Can a management company fine a homeowner?

No. The board decides on fines, and Pennsylvania requires notice and a chance to be heard first. We prepare the notices and records the board needs.

Can homeowners review the association’s records?

Yes. State law says the HOA must make its financial and other records reasonably available to any owner.

How often should a board review its governing documents?

No law sets a schedule. A review every few years, and before any major rule change, catches outdated terms early.